Fiddling in Rome While Our Food Burns

Timothy A. Wise and Marie Brill

Rumor has it that the Roman emperor Nero played a fiddle and sang while Rome burned for five days in the Great Fire of 64. Nearly 2000 years later, at the very site where this devastating fire started so long ago, history is repeating itself, only the leaders doing the fiddling are delegates to the 40th meeting of the UN Committee on World Food Security (CFS). And what’s burning is the world’s food, in the engines of our cars.

Unfortunately this time, the fire didn’t end in five days. Food-based biofuels have been burning for over a decade, the fires are growing in scale and intensity, and there is no end in sight.

It’s not as if we haven’t seen the warning signs. There have been three food price spikes in the last six years, with a wide range of studies implicating biofuels as a key driver of price volatility. How could it be otherwise? In the United States, 40% of our corn—fully 15% of the global corn supply—is now diverted to make ethanol, up from just 5% in 2000.

The food security impacts are multiple and severe. Because ethanol competes for corn with food and animal feed, it has a direct impact on the cost of food. Indeed, in 2008 global food prices doubled. This hurts poor consumers. Biofuels—from corn, sugar, soybeans, and other feedstocks—compete for land and water, putting added stress on scarce resources.

Most dramatically, biofuels producers have been key drivers of large-scale land acquisitions in African and other developing countries.

This is why the CFS put the issue of biofuels and food security on this year’s agenda and commissioned an expert report to inform the decision. Indeed, the report confirmed the negative impacts of biofuels to date and recommended decisive action.

Our own report confirms that one of the main threats to our ability to feed the world in the future is the continued expansion of first generation biofuels.

No matter. At the CFS the fiddling began. Despite urgent statements from the floor about the negative impacts of biofuels on food security, the small group tasked to negotiate a set of principles and actions came up with weak principles and complete inaction. There was no acknowledgement of the negative impacts of biofuel policies and mandates in the United States and European Union, which have been instrumental in artificially stimulating and sustaining the biofuel industry.

Why the fiddling? Simple: the most powerful countries at the negotiating table were the same ones benefiting from the burning of food in our cars. Canada and the United States played the loudest, with the European Union, Brazil, and Argentina playing much the same tune. Only South Africa, a lonely voice, joined with civil society to speak for the victims of these policies.

Of course, the ones choosing the tune were powerful industry interests, from the biofuels companies themselves as well as the agribusiness firms capturing the benefits of high prices and subsidized demand for their products.

The CFS is supposed to be the principal international agency coordinating global responses to the food price crisis and dealing with the new realities of the rising and worrisome integration of food markets with fuel and financial markets. It has that clear mandate.

But instead of leading, the CFS decided to do nothing. The straightforward proposal that biofuels policies that harm food security should be reformed was categorically rejected. So too was any mention of the land and water impacts of runaway biofuels expansion.

The world is not waiting for the CFS to lead. Policy-makers around the world are beginning to contend with food-fuel competition. The U.S. Congress is under pressure to reform, or even repeal, its biofuels mandate. The European Union recently cut its own mandate in half, explicitly recognizing the negative impacts of food-based fuels.

Meanwhile, the fiddling continues, the biofuels burn on.

More than 80 organizations from around the world signed an open letter urging the CFS to take action. Members of civil society formally involved in the CFS negotiations refused to endorse the resolution. “Small scale food producers have spoken powerfully here about the reality they are confronted with every day: that biofuels crops compete with their food production, for the land they till and for the water that sustains them,” they stated in a press release. “[These] recommendations overwhelmingly defend the interests of the biofuels industry and legitimize violations of the right to food.”

This no time for the CFS to fiddle in Rome. Our food is burning. In our cars. And hundreds of millions of people are going hungry.

Timothy A Wise is the Policy Research Director, Global Development and Environment Institute, Tufts University, Medford, and a regular Triple Crisis blogger.  Marie Brill is the executive director of ActionAid USA. She is a member of the Board of Directors of the Jubilee USA Network. For more information about ActionAid, visit

This article originally appeared at Al Jazeera English.

Triple Crisis welcomes your comments.  Please share your thoughts below.

4 Responses to “Fiddling in Rome While Our Food Burns”

  1. […] TripleCrisis This entry was posted in Survive Food Crisis and tagged Burns, Fiddling, Food, Rome. Bookmark the permalink. ← Winds of Change Blow in Asia […]

  2. Go on, enjoy fun this Springtime and organise an Easter Party! Arranging a party to rejoice Easter can be a great deal of fun. Get the creative juices flowing, utilise some careful planning and make sure you’ve plenty of Easter party supplies and you can create a perfect Easter party for Kids’, friends and family!The first thing to do, which lot’s of people forget, is to make sure you actually know when Easter is! This sounds like a ridiculous comment to make but Easter moves each year to a completely different weekend, so be sure you are fully aware of this in the planning stage – especially as you may want to send out RSVP invitations. You could choose to get the kids’ involved right at the start and make some home made invites. Why not grab some card, pens, glue, glitter and other Easter craft goods so that you can spend a day with the children making some personalised Easter party invites. You could shape the card into a range of Easter inspired shapes such as chicks, bunny rabbits or eggs then decorate with glitter, ribbon and other craft essentials. but don’t get too carried away and forget to include all the important information that you require!The next step, tackle the party itself! Get planning well in advance to make sure you’ve covered everything and so that the day can run smoothly. Ensure you’ve receive any RSVP’s from your invites so that you know exactly how many guests to expect enabling you to prepare enough food, arrange presents etc. Decide if you are going to prepare a full meal, a finger buffet or host an outdoor barbecue. Just make sure that you cater for a good range of tastes and have a mix of food and drink that will appeal to most. You could also decide to get the kids’ involved at this stage and get baking some Easter treats for the day, such as cup cakes! Let’s organise the super fun things now! You’ve got to decide on your Easter activities. You’re most likely to include a few traditional Easter party games that would appeal to children and even those young at heart adults! The traditional games, which I am sure you already know, include Easter egg hunts & egg decorating! Plus you’ve the range of competitions like the Easter bonnet competition, egg & spoon races and of course – fancy dress competitions! Depending on what you decide, be sure your invited guests are aware of anything they may need to bring. Of course, you also need to be prepared as well so make sure you have all the supplies you need for your Easter games & activities. Prepare egg hunt treasure maps, hard boil eggs for decorating competitions and start collecting old clothing for the fancy dress competitions.Once it’s all prepared, have a great Easter party!Jennifer Cole
    Hollister Outlet

  3. Activity�� This one is fairly simple and most of us perform it in our daily lives. It is subjected to performing something that relieves the mind from the pressure whether it is personal, related to work or any other endeavors.
    Chaussures Nike Blazer

  4. Book Expo America is one of the most important Trade Shows in the publishing industry. Hotels like The Manhattan Hotel, prepare to welcome attendees to this NY Event by offering a variety of special rates during May and June . View The Manhattan Hotel’s special offers here. Book Expo AmericaWhen: May 29 through June 1Where: Jacob K. Javits Convention Center | 655 West 34th Street | New York, NY 10001For more information call: 1-800-840-5614 Publishers, buyers, authors and others in the industry attend Book Expo America because it is a chance to network, see new products, meet new authors and attend interesting seminars. If a product or service has anything at all to do with the publishing industry then this is the place to see it. Those who can only attend one Trade Show often choose this NY Event. The exhibits are one of the best parts of this NY Event. The exhibit hall features hundreds of tables where you can see samples of new products and discuss the advantages and benefits of the products with vendors. In addition to the exhibits, attendees to Book Expo America can attend special Events such as the Book & Author Breakfast and several others. Keep in mind that these Events have a limited number of seats, and they always sell out, so you��ll want to reserve your spot early. Some of the special guests at this year��s NY Event include Wally Lamb, Ishmael Beah and other well-known authors and celebrities. Publishers and writers who want to learn more about online publishing can find valuable information at this NY Event. You can learn the pros and cons of digital publication as well as how to get started tapping the huge audience of those who prefer online or electronic books. While primarily a Trade Show, organizers of this year��s Book Expo America are opening the NY Event to the public on the final day. For $49, you can purchase a Power Reader admission to Book Expo America. Meet authors and get new books before they hit the stores.
    Ropa Belstaff