Letter from Flint, Michigan

James K. Boyce

The 1936-1937 sit-down strike forced General Motors to recognize the United Auto Workers as the workers’ union.

It began on December 30, 1936, at Fisher Body No. 1 in Flint, Michigan: workers occupied General Motors factories, launching one of the key struggles in U.S. labor history. A Women’s Emergency Brigade brought them food; when the police tried to drive out the strikers with tear gas, the women broke the windows to give them fresh air. After 44 bitter winter days, the sit-down strike forced GM to recognize their union, the United Auto Workers.

It was no accident that Flint was the scene of this historic battle. One hundred years ago, when the city boasted the largest factory in the world – a Buick plant – the people of Flint elected a socialist mayor. But GM founding partner Charles S. Mott won two years later, campaigning on a platform whose first point was “Only men who are successful at business should run city affairs.”

A painting on display at the Alfred P. Sloan museum in Flint depicts the Women’s Emergency Brigade during the sit-down strike of 1936-37.

The U.S. auto industry pioneered not only mass production but also mass consumption. “The American citizen’s first importance to his country is no longer that of citizen but that of consumer,” the pro-business Flint Journal editorialized in 1924. “Consumption is the new necessity.”

By the early 1950s, when I was a baby and my parents moved there, Flint’s workers were earning the highest industrial wages in the nation. In an exhibit called “Flint and the American Dream,” the city’s Sloan Museum displays the household belongings of a typical auto worker of the era: the kitchen appliances, formica countertops, and chrome-and-vinyl furniture, the lawn mower and charcoal grill of my childhood.

Abandoned houses pockmark the author’s old neighborhood.

Flint’s American dream is now a distant memory. Starting in the 1970s, one auto plant after another shut down, a downward slide vividly portrayed in Michael Moore’s film Roger & Me. In the 1981 recession, Flint had the highest unemployment rate in the country. Today, despite the fact that Flint’s population has fallen to less than 60% of what it was in 1960, the city’s unemployment rate still ranks in the top 20 among the country’s 372 metropolitan areas. In the neighborhood of company-built bungalows where I lived as a toddler, the pavements are cracked, the median strips overgrown with weeds, and abandoned, burnt-out houses decay amongst the surviving homes.

How did this reversal of fortunes happen?

The reasons behind Flint’s collapse are not only the greed and sheer ineptitude of General Motors’ management, memorably depicted in Roger & Me, but also monumental public policy failures. These include:

  • massive foreign borrowing, an overvalued dollar and unprecedented trade deficits, beginning in the Reagan era, the fatal macroeconomic nexus that decimated American manufacturing;
  • the failure to grow Medicare into a nationwide single-payer health care system, leaving U.S. firms – alone among those of advanced industrialized countries – saddled with employer-provided health insurance costs that further eroded their competitiveness; and
  • racial divisions, “white flight” to the suburbs, and ill-conceived expressways that tore apart the social capital that was needed to mount an effective local response to these crises.

The grim result is that the American auto industry, which already had pioneered planned obsolescence in consumer goods, went a step further: Flint became a disposable city.

What can we learn today from Flint’s history? In hindsight, the consumption-based social contract espoused by the Flint Journal was not sustainable. It turns out that being a consumer is not a substitute for being a citizen. Caring about things is not more important than caring about each other. Private goodies are not a worthy substitute for public goods. Government cannot be entrusted safely to captains of industry. Our ability to consume cannot be detached from our responsibility to govern ourselves.

So Flint’s American nightmare teaches us this: When we elevate consumption above citizenship, we imperil not only our democracy, but in the end our economy, too.

4 Responses to “Letter from Flint, Michigan”

  1. Very well put. I would add just one thing. Flint was condemned to be disposable in the wake of a bigger movement, one of historical proportions, by which the American power establishment decided that it was time to change the pattern of income distribution: the Volcker recession was just the beginning. It was followed by the Reagan offensive against unions, etc. Dismantling a significant chunk of the US manufacturing industry was just another aspect of this process. Of course, this is when wages started to stagnate and household indebtedness began to grow in earnest. Bubbles and crises followed. So, I would put at the beginning of your list on reasons behind Flint’s collapse the huge (and unresolved) social conflict on distribution. The American right has never accepted the social pact that emerged from the Great Depression. But just how does the American right plan to justify its claim to return and remain in power after the Great Recession?

  2. I really liked your reference to the Flint Journal editorial in 1924. I am writing a long piece called Citizens versus Agents, a long tirade about how ethics was expelled from the discourse on society that later became “social science” (and of course, economics). But this direct reference is a jewel: one is never tired to learn how lucid capital gets in a time of euphoria. For 1924 was a great year for Fordism! Perhaps I should have a section on “Citizens versus Consumers”. Perhaps the fact that citizens lost their souls is the greatest tragedy in American history. But this leads directly to my previous point. US political elites have always relied on the capacity of American capitalism to raise living standards to justify everything in the American political establishment (from the two party system to foreign wars). What will these elites do now if the US enters into a Japanese-style decade of stagnation?

  3. Really enjoy is definitely frail found at nascence, but it surely thrives sturdier as we age should it be suitably federal reserve. [url=http://www.i77.fr/sport-casquette-snapback-casquette-obey-c-7_168_185.html/]casquette obey[/url] casquette obey

  4. It’s hard to come by knowledgeable people on this topic, but you sound like you know what you’re talking about!