Solar energy not war

Sunita Narain

If you know that a sector has arrived when it makes for trade wars between countries, then solar energy clearly has. Last year, the US imposed anti-dumping duties on Chinese imports of solar panels; now the EU has proposed the same. The Chinese have in turn threatened that they will take action against European exports of poly-silicon, the material used for manufacturing solar panels. In February this year, the US filed a case against India at the World Trade Organization (WTO) for “favouring sourcing of panels from domestic manufacturers”. Earlier this month, Canada lost a similar case filed against it at WTO for its support to domestic manufacturers in procurement of solar panels. So, what you thought was all good and nice has suddenly become the biggest bugbear in international trade relations. It tells you that this sector is growing, it is lucrative and it makes for fierce trade politics and competitiveness.

But this is only part of the story. The big issue underlying these “wars” is the role of solar energy—a new source of power to lead the world to a low-carbon future and thus, away from the looming climate crisis. It has big objectives.

First, it has to become cheap so that it can achieve grid parity and compete with the dinosaur in the market: coal and oil. This can only happen when its deployment is greatly scaled up. Secondly, it has to reinvent green growth. This is why solar energy has been “sold” as an alternative industry, which will add to employment. It is the economy of the future. Thirdly, it has to secure needs of the most energy-poor. In other words, this relatively expensive and certainly most modern energy system should reach the poorest millions living in darkness. This would mean cutting the cost of supply, building networks to distribute and doing all that has not been done before.

Solar energy, therefore, has a tall order to deliver. The problem is countries have never considered the competing and often conflicting objectives. As a result, solar energy instead of becoming the messenger of the new cooperative world is getting embroiled in battles.
Consider this. The Chinese have managed to bring down prices and in the process led to the collapse of manufacturing across the world. It is estimated that in 2011 PV modules cost 60 per cent less than what they did in 2008. The first objective of solar energy is close to being met. But cheaper supply from China has hit manufacturing elsewhere. This has led countries to look for options to subsidise their industries and, in turn, damaging others. The US, for instance, provides cheap loans tied to purchase of domestically produced solar systems. Indian solar manufacturing has suffered fatally.

The second objective of using this new industry for green growth is being destroyed. It is for this reason that governments are hitting back.

In all countries the developers—the companies that buy solar systems to install power stations—are objecting to what they call are unnecessary protectionist measures at the behest of inefficient domestic producers. They say cheaper solar power systems have resulted in large-scale deployment, which in turn has given jobs and growth. The result of this powerful push back is that within days of announcing the anti-dumping duties, the US and EU solar associations have issued the Shanghai Declaration asking for a “rule-based trading system” and no duties. Over 1,000 industries have written against the proposal. Hectic parleys are on between the US, EU and China to find a “satisfactory” answer. No doubt these dependent trading partners will find a solution that suits their mutual interests but where will this leave the original purpose of solar power?

This is where the world needs to stop and think. The fact is that countries need manufacturing capacities for domestic employment and to build the future industrial base. The fact also is that solar energy, even with substantial cost reductions, needs policy and financial support for growth. In all this, governments must provide the framework, and not just leave it to the market.

The global aim should be to support this source of power, even if it distorts the so-called market. That’s why it is essential that all trade cases be withdrawn. It should be accepted that countries will provide fiscal support for building manufacturing and that domestic procurement would be facilitated. This is part of the bigger design.

The Indian government must continue with its policy to mandate domestic content in solar installations. But to make it work it should also provide cheap loans—similar to what the US government does through its EXIM Bank—conditional to the purchase of locally produced systems.

Most importantly, the support must be focused on meeting the third objective: reaching clean energy to the poorest. This would mean supporting decentralised power grid that feeds power directly to households. This will not be easy. The cost of such systems is high, cost recovery low and the ability to pay even lower. Let’s remember, the dinosaur can be slain only if there is new energy. New dawn needs new light.

This Piece First Appeared on

Triple Crisis Welcomes Your Comments. Please Share Your Thoughts Below.

6 Responses to “Solar energy not war”

  1. We should not be declaring solar wars or fighting over who supplies or installs what.

    Until the technology has been developed to a stage similar to where we are at now it wouldn’t be suggested for many people to have solar systems as most of the developing areas and classes that would depend on them cannot afford the upfront cost.

    Pay monthly or buyback schemes may be the way forward but many shady installers need to be removed from the scheme.

  2. name says:

    {How solar energy can be produced at competitive cost for the welfare of people at large?Presently what is the status of its use in india?
    |Why can solar energy be not used everywhere? Is it very expensive to tap it?
    |How solar energy can be produced at competitive cost for the welfare of people at large?Presently what is the status of its use in india?
    |Is there any way we can store solar energy into compression of spring and later release springs when we want to run vehicle. Is there any way we can use compressed springs to run motor.

  3. Elena says:

    Website Administrator,

    Are you searching for a method to promote your WEBSITE or BUSINESS?
    If so, read on to discover a website promotion method that costs virtually nothing to implement.
    By the help of Search Engine Optimization, Your business will increase; SEO will get you huge number traffic in just one deal.

    Try this it really works!
    Wouldn’t you like to bring thousands of targeted customers to your site on a regular basis.
    We are Specialize in Article Writing, Link Building, Bookmarking, SMO & SEO.
    We are simple but use powerful, Marketing Strategies for your business, to get more traffic for your website.
    We provide:- Guaranteed Results, Full Transparency, Low SEO Pricing, Free SEO Analysis and Consultation

    Thank & Regards
    Carol Robinson
    Marketing Executive
    SEO Service Provider

  4. This could seem to bea strange problem, nonetheless I’m interested in assessments on the top Real estate brokers in Edmonton, Alberta and am have yet to discover any. There ought to be an area on Local mls where customers can critique their real estate brokers. In the meanwhile I’m in search of some commentary Darlene Strang

  5. Cinda Welms says:

    This may seem likea bizarre inquiry, nevertheless I’m searching for opinions the best Agents in Edmonton, AB and am not finding anything. There needs to be a spot on Local mls where customers can review their real estate professionals. In the mean time I’m trying to find a review Darlene Strang

  6. This could look likea bizarre inquiry, however I’m searching for critical reviews number one Realtors in Edmonton, AB however am have yet to discover any. There needs to be an area on Your local mls where customers can critique their realtors. In the mean time I’m in search of some commentary Edmonton Condo’s and Real Esate, 10805 120 St NW, Edmonton, AB T5H 4L5, Canada (780) 908-3131