Triple Crisis Roundup: The Problem with Reinhart and Rogoff

by Eli Epstein-Deutsch

Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff’s famous ratio of 90% debt-to-GDP, above which countries allegedly begin to experience negative growth, has been cited widely as a justification for austerity by politicians from American Senators Paul Ryan and Tom Coburn to European Commisioner Olli Rehn.  Thus the commentariat have lit up at the recent discovery by Robert Pollin, Michael Ash and Thomas Herndon that Reinhart and Rogoff’s 2010 paper Growth in a Time of Debt contained serious errors, including methodological problems and unwarranted omissions of key data. In their new paper, the University of Massachusetts economists challenge the original growth-rate at the 90% debt-level, which may have been over two percentage points too low: a notable difference. Pundits such as as Paul Krugman have seized on this rebuttal as fresh evidence for a long-standing suspicion that the 90% case was overstated (the correlation never proved the direction of causality, he points out). Defenders of Reinhart and Rogoff such as a Douglas Holtz-Eakin claim that nothing in the takedown really rocks their world (the idea seems to be that debt is intrinsically known to be bad anyway, like sin). With the political tensions over austerity ratcheted up of late, the debate is only likely to heat up from here.

Twitterverse goes nuts over economists clash

Reinhart-Rogoff Paper Cited by Ryan Faulted by Umass Economists

Is Evidence for Austerity Based on a Spreadsheet Error?

How Much Unemployment did Reinhart and Rogoff’s Arithmetic Mistake Cause?

Reinhart-Rogoff, Continued

4 Responses to “Triple Crisis Roundup: The Problem with Reinhart and Rogoff”

  1. […] TripleCrisis This entry was posted in Survive Food Crisis and tagged crisis, Problem, Reinhart, Rogoff, Roundup, Triple. Bookmark the permalink. ← Serious Threat to Asian Economic Model […]

  2. jes extender says:

    I have composed a lot of fine options on pennis workout plans, penis health plus well-being, male organ health plus well-being reviews, penis extenders, penishealth, penis shape penis health, penis health reviews, penis exercises, penis pumps, jelqing, extenze, Tribulus Terrestris and Cialis.

    learn more

  3. A number of all natural solutions to eliminating rapid climaxing.

  4. Bathmate Xtreme X30 is considered the most robust penile hydro pump as of yet.